Contestant Rankings
Scoring Point System (SPS)
-
Originality (30 points)
- Novelty of the research idea or approach.
- Creativity in problem-solving.
- Uniqueness of the research methodology.
-
Methodological Rigor (25 points)
- Clarity and coherence of research methodology.
- Use of appropriate research design.
- Rigorous data collection and analysis.
-
Impact and Practicality (20 points)
- Potential real-world applications of the research findings.
- Relevance to current societal or scientific issues.
- Feasibility of implementation in practical settings.
-
Presentation Quality (15 points)
- Clarity and organization of the research paper or presentation.
- Effectiveness of visual aids (if any).
- Ability to communicate complex ideas clearly.
-
Interdisciplinary Integration (10 points)
- Integration of knowledge from multiple disciplines.
- Contribution to bridging gaps between fields of study.
- Innovation through interdisciplinary collaboration.
Bonus Points:
-
Collaborative Innovation Bonus (+5 points): Awarded for research conducted in collaboration with other teams or institutions, demonstrating synergy and shared intellectual contributions.
-
Ethical Considerations Bonus (+3 points): Awarded for thorough consideration and integration of ethical principles in the research design and implementation.
-
Community Engagement Bonus (+3 points): Recognizes efforts to engage with and incorporate feedback from community stakeholders or end-users in the research process.
Penalty Points:
-
Methodological Flaws Penalty (-5 points): Deducted for significant flaws in research design or execution that undermine the credibility or reliability of findings.
-
Non-compliance Penalty (-3 points): Deducted for failure to adhere to contest guidelines or submission requirements.
Total Points: 100
Judging Criteria:
- Judges will independently score each entry based on the above categories and bonus/penalty points.
- Scores will be averaged across judges to determine final rankings.
- Judges may provide comments and feedback to participants to justify scores.
This system aims to provide a comprehensive evaluation framework that rewards innovation, rigor, practicality, interdisciplinary collaboration, and ethical considerations while penalizing significant methodological flaws and non-compliance with contest rules.
All cumulative scores are based on a ranking scale used by UPENN judges (RAII), which is then combined with other scores.
Cumulative scores
*Out of 30 judges, as of July 8th, 2024, 30 judges have submitted ratings.*
(3,000 pts. attainable)
1st Place -
Whitaker, W. (2024). Mitotic Characteristics in Ductal Carcinoma: Diagnostic and Therapeutic Implications. (2,902 pts.)
2nd Place -
Burch, R. (2024). AI-Assisted Early Detection of Cardiac Arrhythmias: Development and Validation of an ECG-based Prototype Model. (2,899 pts.)
3rd Place -
Chang, H. (2024). Feasibility of Terraforming Mars: Innovative Approaches and Environmental Impact Assessment. (2,812 pts.)
4th Place -
Huynh, D. (2024). Application of Deep Learning Algorithms in Early Detection of Neurodegenerative Disorders: Analysis of Brain Imaging Data. (2,789 pts.)
5th Place -
Beasley, C. (2024). Quantum Entanglement in Secure Communication Systems: Experimental Insights and Potential Applications. (2,701 pts.)
6th Place -
Chung, B. (2024). Optimization of Vertical Axis Wind Turbines (VAWTs) for Urban Environments: Design, Efficiency, and Performance Analysis. (2,598 pts.)
7th Place -
Wong, J. (2024). Optimizing Solar Energy Integration in Residential Communities: Enhancing Efficiency and Storage Capabilities. (2,476 pts.)
8th Place -
Patel, S. (2024). Optimization of Vertical Farming Techniques for Sustainable Crop Production in Limited Space Environments. (2,380 pts.)
9th Place -
Jacobs, C. (2024). Impact of Microplastics on Coastal Marine Life: Case Study on Shellfish Populations in Maine. (2,193 pts.)
10th Place -
Roberts, O. (2024). Feasibility and Benefits of Green Roofs in Urban Environments: Enhancing Sustainability and Mitigating Urban Heat Island Effects. (1,736 pts.)